L1® Users Forum    Bose L1® Musicians  Hop To Forum Categories  Instrument Forums  Hop To Forums  Guitars and Other Strings    Help! Should i learn Guitar or Violin? Pros and Cons of Both?
Page 1 2 
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
Help! Should i learn Guitar or Violin? Pros and Cons of Both?
 Login/Join
 
posted
Hi, i'm a singer and a songwriter, but i want to learn to play an instrument too. I'm twenty years old, but dedicated.
I'm torn between acoustic guitar which everyone tells me is the logical choice (the cliche is my reply), or the violin which i love the sound of.

Could you tell me the pros and cons of learning each?
How long on average can i expect to take to reach proficiency if not pro in either of these?
I can only afford a half hour private lessons a week, but will practice about two hours a day.
Which instrument is the easiest to handle? (especially for a left hander).
 
Posts: 1 | Registered: Thu December 01 2005Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of Dewey
posted Hide Post
Hi Rainbowserpant.......

The guitar would be much easier to master than the violin and would seem more logical for a singer, provided it is an instrument that you are interested in. The violin is considered one of the most difficult of the stringed instruments to master. Also depending on the different opinions you hear, there is a disticnt difference between playing violin and fiddle. Two different techniques and sounds involved.

If as you say you are going to practice 2 hours per day as well as take lessons you should do reasonably well in whichever instrument you choose.

Good luck in whichever you select.

Dewey


"Classic country music is the best"
 
Posts: 177 | Location: Michigan | Registered: Sun August 08 2004Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
quote:
How long on average can i expect to take to reach proficiency if not pro in either of these?


A short-time and a life-time ...

I'd pick guitar as well if you want to sing. Also, violin may make you deaf in your left ear over time. It is VERY loud up that close.

You can learn the basics of guitar in a half-year and be proficient within a couple. But I've found that you can grow with the instrument for your entire life. Les Paul, is a famous guitar player and inventor. He's 90 this year and according to him "still learning". how cool is that?

Steve
 
Posts: 2560 | Location: Framingham, MA | Registered: Thu October 02 2003Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
I recall an interview with Chet Atkins ,after he was already a legend, where he said that he was taking guitar lessons. Who could teach Chet?
Making music seems to be a passion that few ever "get over".
Due to limited dexterity I don't get much better, but at 63 I am always learning new stuff about guitar and music.
Respect
Col. Andy
 
Posts: 646 | Location: Central Kentucky | Registered: Sun December 05 2004Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of Tom Munch
posted Hide Post
My experience with the violin is that you're either very good or very bad, & it takes a lot of playing to get to be very good.
 
Posts: 3806 | Location: Pueblo West, Colorado | Registered: Wed June 30 2004Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of Noel in California at his house!
posted Hide Post
Tom’s right on with this one! I tried picking up the Violin many, many years ago after playing the guitar for about 15 years at that time! There is no obvious frets, so if you get lost, It’s much harder to recover from then with a guitar. I too love the sound of a good violin but I recognized right off that I had no talent for it… You should try renting, and trying out both for a while and see which one lands with you….

Oddly enough one of my favorite instruments to play is the harp. Back in the early 70s I thought it was just a back ground instrument until I saw Harpo Marks play take me out to the ball park on one. Well I just had to have one after that. I was surprise on how easy it was to learn to play.

Try not to limit your self to just one instrument… you are young… just imagine how fulfilling life would be if you could master one every ten years!
 
Posts: 316 | Registered: Wed October 12 2005Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
Good question: violin or guitar? I started the violin at 26, played the violin for 5 years and quit to play classical guitar for 5 years, then back to the violin, which I have been playing as an amatueur for the last 15 years. I'll break my answer into categories:

Musical need: Do you need to play melody or rhythm? You can do both with each instrument, but if melody is your desire, violin it is. A violin sustains a pitch, like the voice, and produces a melody that a plucked string can't.

Cost: guitars are way, way cheaper than violins. You'll need a decent violin to start and a better violin in two or three years. A better violin is critical, because it makes the pitches easier to hear and find.

Left handed: It will be easier for you to learn the fiddle as a lefty, because beginning and intermediate fiddlers struggle with the left hand. It takes years to realize that it's the right hand, the bow hand, that produces the sound, despite the fact that you know this and everybody tells you.

Lessons: critical to violin playing. It is so much easier to learn something new and correctly, than take years to eliminate a bad habit. Because the violin is held the way it is (or should be) there are a lot of long-term bad things you can do to yourself if you don't hold it and play it correctly.

Time to get good: This is of course, subjective, but it took me three or four years to be an intermediate guitarist and six to eight years to be an intermediate violinist. But I've met fiddlers who astonish me that have only been playing five years. The violin was a lot harder than the guitar for me -- I was actually shocked at how much easier the gross finger movement was than the subtle left hand on the violin.

Violin vs fiddle. If your goal is finely played classical violin, you're too late. I've never met a fine classical violinist who didn't play in junior high. You can, on the other hand, be a great fiddler if you are patient. (I gave up on classical violin and became a fiddler five years ago. Never regretted it for an instant.) Fiddling is growing in numbers and importance. Search for "fiddle camps" and explore. I play for contra dances and just love it.

There are lots of opportunities for guitar players too, but I am not familiar with them.

Musical Styles: the violin can play all musical styles, and does. I play with an English Dance band that plays music from 1650 to 1850. I play with a contradance band that plays contemporary music.

The violin/fiddle is a lead instrument -- do you want to be a leader? (Now, however, I'm learning rhythm fiddle and second fiddle, and I love it.) Most string bands have fiddle leads, not guitar. Most rock bands have guitar leads, not fiddles -- but that is because the fiddle is harder to play.

What to choose? I'm patient and I love the ability to move the pitch around of a sustained tone. The fiddle is a lot harder than the guitar, but if you choose it, you'll love it.

Robert
 
Posts: 5 | Location: Glastonbury, Connecticut | Registered: Fri October 07 2005Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of captbanjo
posted Hide Post
I'm curious Col., because I no longer rank as a spring chicken, do you still play out? Have you found any major problems performing as you've aged? Jagger still struts around and Sir Paul is hitting the road.

Wayne

quote:
Originally posted by Col. Andy:
Making music seems to be a passion that few ever "get over".
Due to limited dexterity I don't get much better, but at 63 I am always learning new stuff about guitar and music.
Respect
Col. Andy
 
Posts: 914 | Location: Rhode Island, USA | Registered: Sun December 14 2003Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
Well, I can't strut like Jagger (never could), but I do still play bars, parties etc. I used to be a 6 night a week solo/duo player, but I don't want to work that much now, maybe 25 or 30 gigs each year. I do depend more on my notes and lyric sheets these days, but the voice still seems to hold up OK. Setting up my old PA was getting hard on my back, and along comes Bose with the PAS and solved that problem. I don't plan to stop until either my show or my body quits working. Smile
Respect

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Col. Andy,
 
Posts: 646 | Location: Central Kentucky | Registered: Sun December 05 2004Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of FingerStyle
posted Hide Post
Hey lets look at this, you can learn one key on the violin in a year, or you can learn how to play the guitar very well in a year. Lets face it Carlos Santana's father started him on the violin, now he is a guitarist........
 
Posts: 1 | Registered: Fri January 06 2006Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of Michael Nunley
posted Hide Post
MIDI Control from violin still stinks... but guitar is very useable.

If you break a guitar string, you can find a set in any town with a population greater than 300.

Have you seen how much it costs to re-hair a bow ??

You EVER see someone sing and play the violin at the same time ?
 
Posts: 822 | Registered: Thu October 21 2004Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
Hi
i I am a fiddler player that started at age 24, 30 years ago. I was playing out pretty soon at that time. I entered music scholl at age 27 and studied the violin for 7 years. I l also play mandolin, which is a good double and a good way to add something to a band relatively quickly. I also play a little guitar. These days I play a version of folk/jazz with some blues and celtic music. By all means go for the fiddle with perhaps adding the mandolin at the same time. There are a gazillion guitar players, and very few good fiddlers. In spite of what another post says, the real difficukty in learning the violin/fiddle is the mastery of the bow. Where are you located ? I may be able to help you if you are near Cleveland Ohio. I taught for many years, adults and children and because I started late, I have an intellectual approach rather than instinctive to teaching. Violin playing has a great deal of physics involved with the manipulation of speed, pressure, and location of the bow.

Go for it ! The hard work you put in now will pay off with a unique sound.

John Reynolds
 
Posts: 9 | Registered: Fri May 26 2006Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
i am not sure why everyone is saying that guitar is easier. to become a virtuoso of the classical guitar takes just as many years as it does to become a virtuoso of any other classical instrument. while unfretted instruments do present the challenge of intonation, the guitar offers the challenge of multi simultaneous voicing. your fretting hand can be doing 3- different tings on 3-4 different fingers while your right hand is doing 4-5 different things, add to this two more strings than the violin and you get start to get the picture. if not, please listen to some of john williams (the guitarist, not film scorer) recordings of j.s. bach. jullian bream, christopher parkening, andres segovia and of course randy pile are guitar virtuosos. pepe romero is another. in the classical style reading notation is a must and getting good tone requires much more than amp and eq settings. i used to play electric all the time as well as steel string acoustic, violin, double bass and piano. the guitar is by no means easier unless you are trying to do easy playing. i imagine the same is for all the other instruments. virtuosity is not about the instrument its about the instrumentalist, as is mastery.
 
Posts: 1 | Registered: Thu September 03 2009Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of captbanjo
posted Hide Post
As I see it, in a short time a player can 'get by' on the guitar. In order to 'get by' on the five-string banjo it took me much more work. I shudder to consider the fiddle.

True that mastery on a guitar takes a lifetime of work. But many rock and pop stars learned three or four chords and took off. A little effort goes a long way on guitar IMO. Also ideal for singers I believe. On the other hand, the Atkins fingerstyle tunes I'm trying to learn are taxing me.
 
Posts: 914 | Location: Rhode Island, USA | Registered: Sun December 14 2003Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
Hi

I was a percussionist who sang. I wanted to accompany myself as a solo singer and found that drums and vocals really would not back me very well. Neither will Violin alone. I learned guitar and then went on to keyboard. Your a singer and a songwriter........your decision is simple. Learn to play the acoustic guitar and concentrate on chords and progressions. Depending on how much practice time you want to put in you should be up and running and singing around a campfire or doing a solo on stage at some local pub in a reasonable short time. Good Luck!

AJ
 
Posts: 605 | Registered: Wed March 07 2007Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of tpryde3
posted Hide Post
My wife is an outstanding violinist (though she mostly plays cello these days), and I am passable at it (read: not in public). I have been playing guitar (both classical and fingerstyle) for 15-20 years or so, and I am still working toward mastering the instrument (2-3 hours a day, as well as touring full time). I have some familiarity with both instruments, and while I do have an opinion on which is more challenging to begin (violin), mastery is equally difficult with both instruments.

So here is my advise...

Since both instruments are equally hard to master (just different), pick up whichever one excites you the most. Consider this: studies have shown that it takes approximately 10,000 hours of practice to master almost anything. This means that you are going to put some serious time and effort in so that you can master it.

In light of the work and time involved, you sure don't want to be playing an instrument that you don't enjoy fully. On top of this, the more you enjoy it, the more likely it is that your audience with enjoy it as well. So by all means, take lessons. You won't regret doing the hard work it takes to learn to play well.

On the other hand, if you are simply looking for something to learn and then take gigging in the shortest possible time, go with the guitar. Though at your age this seems short sighted; take the time and effort to learn it well.

Regarding teachers...never stop taking lessons. I have two different teachers (one on the West coast and one on the East), and every lesson is valuable. I have two songs written recently, simply because of some ideas and techniques from my last lesson. Play with others and learn as much as you can from every musician you meet, regardless of their instrument. You will be enriched, and you will enrich others.

Hopefully you will indulge me one last maxim: your music will only be as communicative to the extent that the river of your experience runs deep. So practice thoroughly, and live so that you will be able to give full voice to the richness that surrounds you.


Tom

What happens when you give a pastor a guitar and teach him to sing? You get a Sermon in Song
 
Posts: 83 | Location: Touring | Registered: Wed March 26 2008Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
Can anybody help me with finding fun violin music? I love country music, but am having a hard time finding anything and am just learning... looking for something to look forward to as i learn ;-)
 
Posts: 1 | Registered: Sat October 31 2009Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
Picture of captbanjo
posted Hide Post
Jamie, not sure if you're aware that this is a forum for the Bose L1 and family systems. But we do go off target a lot.

Check Homespun and Hal Leonard sites. There should be enough beginner dvds and cds and books to keep you busy for the next decade or so.
 
Posts: 914 | Location: Rhode Island, USA | Registered: Sun December 14 2003Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
Guitar is more useful for a song writer, however, my daughter is a very good violin player. After a few lessons, now she is a very discent guitar player. Lesson? Violin skills are normally transferred to other string instruments. Just an idea...


Roberto Belen
 
Posts: 3 | Location: Sumter, South Carolina | Registered: Mon November 09 2009Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
posted Hide Post
I know this is like 4 years old and you probably already made your decision, but I'll reply for any other people with the same question.

I've tried both instruments and my personal preference is the violin. I had tried learning guitar twice previously in the past and I recently bought a guitar and have been learning that, but the violin still gets more use out of it.

Although the violin doesn't have any frets, I still find it easier to place my fingers on the strings than I do with the guitar. I've heard that violin intonation comes much easier to singers, so that may have something to do with it. Since you're also a singer, I imagine you would find it easier too.

Now from what I know about guitar, is the approach to songs is quite different. With the violin, it takes more of a melodic approach and going through a song is more or less the same approach as when you sing a song. Guitar takes more of a harmonic approach by playing chords that go along with what you sing.

Now one of the pros with a guitar is it a popular instrument and finding music resources is much easier, the cost is somewhat less than for the violin, and it's more popular in mainstream music. Those are some of the reasons I wanted to learn guitar.

I love the sound of the violin and hearing the music I am playing is definitely enjoyable and learning it has come so naturally for me. I was able to get up to an intermediate level in under a year with private lessons, so it may not take as long as some people think.

Anyways that's some of the pros and cons from the point of view of somebody who prefers the violin.
 
Posts: 1 | Registered: Thu November 19 2009Reply With QuoteAsk Bose for help
  Powered by Social Strata Page 1 2  
 

    L1® Users Forum    Bose L1® Musicians  Hop To Forum Categories  Instrument Forums  Hop To Forums  Guitars and Other Strings    Help! Should i learn Guitar or Violin? Pros and Cons of Both?


Bose | Privacy Statement | Terms of Service
© Bose® Corporation 2003-2011